Selecting the best platform to sell your Beanie Babies can greatly influence your success and profitability. Two platforms often considered are SellBeanies.com and Sell4Value.com.
You Just Cannot Trust Sell4Value (here’s why…)
The crazy part about Sell4Value is they buy your beanies for 25 cents each and then immediately turn around and sell them on their other website at TreasureKeepers.com for 20-30x more.
Sell4Value / TreasureKeeper.com is the same exact company. Just look at this:
Now take a look at this. First, you can see their offer page for a common beanie baby, the 1999 Ty Signature Beanie Baby.
They are paying $0.25 per beanie baby. (SellBeanies.com pays more).
Also, take a look at that 2-3 week processing time – it takes forever to get paid there!
Now, just head on over to their storefront and you can see they are immediately taking this beanie they are offering 25 cents for… and selling it for $6 bucks! That’s a 24X INCREASE IN PRICE!
Just take a look – they even use the exact same picture…
There is just NO reason to choose Sell4Value!
Overview of SellBeanies.com – The Better Choice
SellBeanies.com buys all of your Beanie Babies at once and pays for all the shipping costs. It is by far the easiest way to sell your Beanie Babies online today.
Pros of SellBeanies.com:
- Easy To Use:
- The primary advantage of SellBeanies.com is how easy it is to use. Simply count your beanie babies, fill out the form, get your prepaid shipping label, and get paid for your beanie babies quickly.
- Quick Payments
- You’ll get paid fast via PayPal, Zelle, or Venmo.
- All Shipping Costs Taken Care Of
- The platform completely covers all shipping costs so you make as much profit as possible.
- No Selling Fees:
- Typically, niche marketplaces charge fees to sell (eBay charges about 20%). There are zero fees with SellBeanies.com
Cons of SellBeanies.com:
- Condition Matters
- SellBeanies does not accept beanies without tags, bent tags, or stains/odors.
Overview of Sell4Value.com
Sell4Value.com is the same company as TreasureKeeper.com, a retail site that sells Beanie Babies. They will buy your beanies for cheap and then immediately sell them for 20-30x the price on their other site.
Cons of Sell4Value.com:
- They Don’t Pay You As Much As Others
- Unlike SellBeanies.com, Sell4Value.com pays just 25 cents per beanie baby, as you can see in the example shown above. SellBeanies pays you more $$$!
- Complex Interface:
- The platform’s interface is designed to handle various product categories, making it less intuitive and user-friendly for sellers focused solely on Beanie Babies. Navigating through the site and creating effective listings can be cumbersome.
- Very Slow Processing Times
- Sell4Value.com tells you to expect 2-3 weeks of processing time. This means you have to send your beanies to them without getting paid and then wait for close to a month to start the process of getting paid.
- You Pay For Shipping
- Sell4Value.com makes you cover all the shipping costs unless you meet a minumum amount.
- Very Strict on Condition
- Your beanies need to be in pristine condition to get accepted. If they are not accepted, you are responsible to pay for return shipping which decreases your profit even further.
- Doesn’t Take Everything / Limits Duplicates
- You cannot sell your entire collection as there are limits to the number of duplicates accepted. (SellBeanies.com takes everything, including all duplicates).
Detailed Comparison
- SellBeanies.com: Easy to use, buys everything including duplicates, pays the most, covers all shipping costs upfront, pays fast.
- Sell4Value.com: Pays low prices and then turns around and immediately resells for 20x more, slow processing times, slow payment times, strict acceptance rate, doesn’t take duplicates.
Conclusion
When comparing SellBeanies.com to Sell4Value for selling Beanie Babies, SellBeanies.com emerges as the clear winner. Choose SellBeanies.com if you want to make the most money selling your beanie babies.
