A common question we get asked is “how do I sell my beanie baby collection?”
This guide will give you all the info you need to do it the right way!
SellBeanies.com
Pros:
- Easy To Use: SellBeanies.com makes it incredibly easy to sell all of your Beanies Babies at once. We pay one flat rate per Beanie Baby so you just need to count them up and give us the total number that you want to sell!
- We Pay All Shipping: Unlike other buyers, we pay you upfront for all shipping costs and even email you the prepaid shipping labels. All you need to do is box up your beanies and tape on the label.
- We Buy Everything, Even Duplicates: We buy all regular sized Beanie Babies as long as they have tags, no stains/odors, and no bent tags. Have 10 of one beanie? That’s fine, we’ll take all of them – no limit!
Cons:
- None: SellBeanies.com is the best way to sell your beanie baby collection.
Tips for Selling on SellBeanies.com:
- Follow the step by step directions here.
- Count the total number of Beanie Babies you want to sell.
- Put them in a box, print out the prepaid shipping label, and turn your Beanie Babies collection into cash!
Ready to sell your Beanie Babies? Get started today – we’ll buy your entire collection and cover all shipping costs.
eBay
Pros:
- Large Audience: eBay is one of the largest online marketplaces, attracting hundreds of thousands of Beanie Babies listed for sale.
- Auction Rare Beanies: Ideal for rare Generation 1 or Generation 2 Beanie Babies.
- Global Reach: You can sell to buyers worldwide, increasing your chances of finding high-paying collectors who specialize in Generation 1 Beanies.
Cons:
- Fees: eBay charges listing fees and takes close to 20% in fees of the final sale price.
- Shipping Costs: You are responsible for finding the best priced, most reliable shipping method.
- Competition: High competition means your listing needs to stand out with quality photos and descriptions. There are hundreds of thousands of beanies already listed for sale.
Tips for Selling on eBay:
- Use high-quality images showing all angles and all tags with detailed descriptions.
- Research and set a competitive starting price.
- Offer international shipping to attract more buyers.
- Offer free shipping to get buyers motivated to buy from you.
Etsy
Pros:
- Vintage and Handmade Focus: Etsy’s audience is geared towards handmade beanie babies.
- Community Feel: Etsy has a community of dedicated buyers who appreciate unique items.
Cons:
- Smaller Audience: While dedicated, Etsy’s audience is smaller compared to eBay.
- Fees: Listing and transaction fees apply, similar to eBay’s fees.
Tips for Selling on Etsy:
- Create a compelling shop with a clear brand.
- Use high-quality photos and emphasize any unique features of your Beanie Babies.
- Engage with the Etsy community through social media and forums.
Additional Tips for Selling Beanie Babies Online
- Research: Know the value of your Beanie Babies and list accordingly. Be sure to understand if you have any rare beanies by learning more about beanie baby hang tags.
- Photos: High-quality images increase trust and attract buyers.
- Descriptions: Be detailed and honest about the condition and any unique features.
- Shipping: Package items securely and consider offering insurance for valuable Beanie Babies.
Conclusion
Selling Beanie Babies online can be highly profitable if you choose the right platform and follow best practices. Whether you opt for SellBeanies.com, eBay, Etsy, etc, understanding the pros and cons of each platform will help you make informed decisions and maximize your sales. Happy selling!
